The 9 Best Toilet Plungers

What To Look For in a Toilet Plunger

A toilet plunger is to a bathroom what a screwdriver is to a toolbox: A simple, inexpensive item you’re sure to need at some point. It’s the first thing you should reach for when your toilet clogs. Most of the time, it’s the only tool you’ll need for that purpose.

First, know the difference between a toilet plunger and a sink plunger. A toilet plunger is specifically made to fit inside the toilet opening; a wide, flat-rimmed sink plunger isn’t. The rounded shape of a toilet plunger tapers into a small opening, and a long handle keeps you at a safe distance.

If you’ve been using a sink plunger for your toilet, you probably haven’t had much success. Your should own both, but if you only have room in your bathroom for one, make it a toilet plunger. You have other options for cleaning sink clogs, such as disassembling the P-trap.

Over the years manufacturers introduced innovative design elements to improve plunging power and ease of use. Some models offer the same domed shape as a sink plunger but with a tapered flange. Others resemble beehives, and still others feature bellows. You’ll find a T-handle on some models that makes them easier to handle and pump.

Consider these features when shopping for the best toilet plunger:

• Shape: The beehive shape is the most effective. It features a larger volume than the traditional dome shape and it’s easier to fill with water than a model with bellows. (By the way, you should always fill your toilet plunger with water before pumping. Otherwise, you’re just pumping compressible air that will probably escape through the toilet vent before it gets to an obstruction deep in the pipes.) The third option — the flanged cup — is almost as effective as the beehive, and it’s a more versatile.
• Plunger material: Either rubber or malleable plastic. Rubber is best because it’s flexible, long-lasting and doesn’t leave marks on the toilet bowl. Choose synthetic rubber if you don’t like the smell of natural rubber.
• Handle: Go for the T-handle. A plunger with a straight handle will work just fine, and some models feature plastic handles molded for easy gripping. You’ll develop more plunging pressure, however, if you have a bar to apply vertical force.