Zero Covidence in China

World leaders are increasingly deciding that their countries need to figure out how to live with Covid-19 rather than minimize the number of cases.

Britain, France, Denmark, Turkey and other parts of Europe have loosened restrictions. Australia has dropped mask mandates and reopened its border. South Africa has lifted curfews and required schools to open fully.

China is doing none of this.

As the Beijing Olympics begin, China continues to pursue a “zero Covid” policy. The Olympics will have few fans. As it has for almost two years, China responds to new outbreaks by imposing strict lockdowns. In the northwestern city of Lanzhou last year, officials told roughly four million people to stay home in response to fewer than 50 known cases.

China’s strategy has had both major successes (holding deaths to low levels) and major costs (disrupting daily life even more than in other countries). It makes for a fascinating case study at a time when Americans disagree vehemently — and often along partisan lines — about whether to maintain Covid precautions or return to normal.

China’s strategy would obviously not be possible in a country that emphasizes individual rights as much as the U.S. does. But China’s strategy does show what a society can do when it makes the prevention of Covid its No. 1 priority, almost regardless of the side effects.

A question that experts are asking now is whether China’s strategy is sustainable, given the contagiousness of Omicron. For now, China’s leaders are sticking with it.

The benefits

Data coming out of China can be suspect, and local officials apparently undercounted Covid cases early in the pandemic to hide the scale of the outbreak. But most experts believe the country’s official Covid counts have been at least close to accurate for most of the past two years.

That’s partly because big outbreaks are hard to cover up, and partly because China’s leadership has threatened to punish officials who hide cases. As Amy Qin, a Times correspondent who covers China, told us, “Local officials have every incentive to find the infections and stop the spread before they get out of hand.”

Even if China’s official numbers are artificially low, its true Covid death toll is almost certainly much lower than that of the U.S., Europe or many other countries. Consider how enormous the official gap is:

The zero-Covid policy has also allowed some forms of normalcy to return. Masks are required in public, but unless a city is in lockdown, people have been attending parties and eating in restaurants for most of the past two years, Amy notes.

When Covid began spreading in Wuhan, it seemed as if it might have the potential to weaken the Communist Party’s standing. Instead, China’s success at controlling Covid has turned into a public relations triumph for the regime. President Xi Jinping uses China’s management of the virus to bolster his global campaign for influence, arguing that China’s system of government works better than Western democracies do.

The downsides

China’s maximalist approach has had harmful side effects.

Even modest outbreaks can lead local officials to place millions of people under lockdown, sometimes with terrible consequences. As our colleague Li Yuan has written:

In the northwestern city of Xi’an, hospital employees refused to admit a man suffering from chest pains because he lived in a medium-risk district. He died of a heart attack.

They informed a woman who was eight months pregnant and bleeding that her Covid test wasn’t valid. She lost her baby.

Two community security guards told a young man they didn’t care that he’d had nothing to eat after catching him out during the lockdown. They beat him up.

Lockdowns have also hurt Chinese businesses and the global economy. One reason that inflation has risen around the world is that Chinese factories and ports have been quick to shut down when there are nearby cases, disrupting supply chains.

Chinese officials maintain that zero Covid is still viable. If that’s correct, the approach may need to become even more aggressive, given that the Omicron variant is so contagious. China’s two major vaccines appear to provide significant protection against serious illness but little protection against infection.

China also has little natural immunity, unlike countries where the virus has spread widely. “That immunity gap between China and the outside world is only increasing,” Yanzhong Huang, a global health expert at the Council on Foreign Relations, told us. Some other countries that previously had zero-Covid strategies, like Singapore and New Zealand, have recently moved away from them.

China seems to face a choice “between short-term pain and long-term pain,” Huang said. Maintaining zero Covid would probably require long-lasting social and economic disruptions; giving it up would invite a rapid surge of infections. “But after that you could be in much better shape,” Huang said.

It does seem possible that China will start to shift its approach after the Olympics, perhaps experimenting with fewer restrictions in some cities and regions. Already, some Chinese health officials have subtly altered their message. “They are emphasizing more now the idea of responding rapidly and nimbly to small outbreaks to get as close to zero as possible,” Amy says.

One factor may be a growing fatigue among Chinese people. While the zero-Covid strategy seems still to have widespread support, some Chinese citizens seem to be growing more frustrated with strict lockdowns. “We are definitely seeing more grumbling from people,” Amy said. “There is a growing sense that you could get caught in a lockdown at any time.”

Related: Activists are urging Olympic athletes to speak out about human rights. China’s government has reminded them that Chinese law applies to them while they are in Beijing.

In Times Opinion, Maura Elizabeth Cunningham argues that this year’s Games are about spotlighting Xi’s control.

A programming note: Starting this weekend, The Morning expands to seven days a week. Melissa Kirsch will write on Saturdays about culture and German Lopez on Sundays about big stories and ideas.

THE LATEST NEWS

ISIS Raid

• President Biden said a U.S. raid had killed Abu Ibrahim al-Hashimi al-Qurayshi, the leader of ISIS, in northwest Syria.

• At least 13 people died in the raid. U.S. officials said most were killed when al-Qurayshi detonated explosives.

• Neighbors described the hourslong raid, including messages blared over a loudspeaker and heavy gunfire.

Politics

• “The answer is not to defund the police,” Biden said at an event with New York City police officers, alongside Mayor Eric Adams.

• Some senators of both parties oppose Dr. Robert Califf, Biden’s nominee to run the F.D.A.

Business and Tech

• Meta’s stock dropped sharply, erasing more than $230 billion in the company’s value and setting off Wall Street’s biggest drop in nearly a year.

• Amazon said it was raising the price of its Prime membership to compensate for increased costs.

• A change to Apple’s privacy features is tormenting tech giants.

• Jeff Zucker, who resigned as CNN’s president this week, was “joined at the hip” with the executive with whom he had a relationship.

Other Big Stories

• Starting this spring, Medicare patients will be able to pick up free rapid coronavirus tests at pharmacies.

• One of Ahmaud Arbery’s killers affirmed his plea of not guilty in a hate crimes case after his proposed plea deal was rejected by a judge.

• Under pressure from the West, Vladimir Putin is turning to China.

• After disrupting travel and power across the U.S., a sprawling winter storm is moving into the Northeast.

Opinions

David Brooks spoke to the Christians trying to save evangelicalism from misogyny, racism and Donald Trump.

Georgetown Law is wrong — strategically and in principle — to punish a recent conservative hire for his ugly tweets, says Michelle Goldberg.

MORNING READS

Below the ice: Adventurers and scientists will search for one of the world’s great shipwrecks.

@ElonJet: A teenager tracked Elon Musk’s jet on Twitter. Then came the direct message.

Vintage finds: Malaysia got in on the secondhand clothing boom.

Modern Love: A daily reminder of mortality can be more gift than burden.

Advice from Wirecutter: Good detergent beats a good dishwasher.

Lives Lived: Robin Herman, a Times hockey reporter, was one of the first female journalists in North America to enter the locker room of a men’s pro team. She died at 70.

SPORTS AND IDEAS

Olympians to watch

The opening ceremony of the Beijing Winter Olympics takes place this morning. Here’s a preview of a few events:

Snowboarding: Chloe Kim — the breakout star of the last Winter Games — is a favorite to win gold in the halfpipe again. Shaun White, 35, the three-time gold medalist, is back for what he says will be his final Olympics.

Speedskating: Last year, Erin Jackson became the first Black woman to win a speedskating World Cup event. But she almost didn’t make the Olympics because of a stumble in her qualifying tournament. Her teammate Brittany Bowe gave up her spot in the 500 meters for Jackson. Bowe will compete in the 1,000 and 1,500 meters.

Figure skating: At 22, Nathan Chen has won nearly everything but a gold medal, after a disastrous routine kept him off the podium in 2018. He is a favorite again.

Freestyle skiing: Eileen Gu grew up in San Francisco, but she will compete for China, her mother’s home country, where she is a budding superstar. The 18-year-old phenom has a shot at three gold medals.

Bobsled: Among the new events this year is the monobob, a one-woman bobsled race. Elana Meyers Taylor, an American, would be a favorite in the event, unless a positive Covid test keeps her out of the race.

For more, follow The Times’s live coverage of the opening ceremony.

PLAY, WATCH, EAT

What to Cook

This sheet-pan fried rice with vegan “XO” sauce is delightful.

What to Listen to

On her new album “Laurel Hell,” Mitski delves into electronics and darkness.

And Just Like That …

The show’s over.

Take the News Quiz

How well did you keep up with the headlines this week?

Late Night

The hosts discussed Rudy Giuliani on “The Masked Singer.”

Now Time to Play

The pangram from yesterday’s Spelling Bee was anchovy. Here is today’s puzzle — or you can play online.

Here’s today’s Mini Crossword, and a clue: Ceaselessly (five letters).

If you’re in the mood to play more, find all our games here.

Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. — David

P.S. Facebook launched 18 years ago today.

Here’s today’s front page.

“The Daily” is about zero Covid. On “The Ezra Klein Show,” Jamal Greene discusses the Supreme Court.

Claire Moses, Tom Wright-Piersanti, Ashley Wu and Sanam Yar contributed to The Morning. You can reach the team at [email protected].

Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox.